Hearty congratulations to Manchester United. They might have left it late but they’ve managed to lift the prestigious Most Pathetic Complaint of the Year award for 2017. All that caterwauling about Manchester City celebrating with inappropriate vigour after winning the derby at Old Trafford clinched it for them.
Can you imagine any greater admission of competitive impotence than complaining that the opposition made too much of a fuss about beating you? It’s like something a wounded teacher would come up with at the end of a primary schools blitz. It’s hilarious.
The funniest thing of all is that the complaints are led by a man whose single most famous moment is perhaps his jubilant sprint down the touchline when Porto scored an unlikely win in the 2004 Champions League. Who were their opposition again? Manchester United. Where was the game played? Old Trafford.
And when Inter Milan beat Barcelona in the 2010 competition, The Guardian’s Amy Lawrence wrote, “Mourinho scampered across the sacred turf of Camp Nou, then struck a pose, a gesture of rampant defiance, aimed at the pocket of Inter fans up in the gods. This was yet another milestone moment that this singular coach intended to milk to the full.” Barcelona’s manager that night? Pep Guardiola.
Mourinho has always loved rubbing it into the opposition. Yet if an opposing manager went on one of those runs he would probably try to rugby tackle him, or at least whine afterwards about the transgression of one of those ‘unwritten rules’ often invoked by sore losers in an effort to distract from their failure.
The Mourinho whose amour propre was offended by the sight of excessively jubilant Blues is a very different one from the lad who frolicked in the Nou Camp seven years ago. His Champions League triumph with Inter Milan was his greatest managerial achievement. But the years in Spain which followed increasingly seem like a watershed moment. He arrived at Real Madrid as the undisputed numero uno in world management. By the time he left the crown had been ceded to Pep Guardiola, something which the United manager has never been able to accept.
At the heart of Mourinho’s latest crankiness explosion is his belief that in some way Guardiola is defrauding him. He’s vague about the precise manner in which this underhand feat has been achieved but insistent that something is not quite kosher about the Manchester City manager. This is the dark side of Mourinho’s enormous self-belief. If you really are The Special One, then anyone who does better than you must be cheating in some way.
That top managers hate to lose is a given, yet Mourinho’s inability to accept defeat verges on the pathological. After a big loss he can resemble one of those Japanese soldiers sniping away in the jungles for decades after World War II ended, unwilling to believe that the conflict is over and their side lost.
You can praise him for this and say it displays a magnificent never-say-die spirit. But a manager who doesn’t accept that he has been beaten fair and square is less likely to take the measures necessary to prevent future defeats by the same opposition. If there’s something hooky about Guardiola’s success, then Mourinho is absolved of all personal responsibility for being bested by him. It is up to other people to rid him of this turbulent Catalan.
Perhaps in private Mourinho is fully aware of the shortcomings of his approach compared to Guardiola’s. But in public his preoccupation was with creating a smokescreen which would obscure the reality of what transpired during last Sunday’s derby and what it said about the current disparity in performance between the two clubs.
The jibe at the City players for lacking education was presumably some kind of personal dig. It usually is with Mourinho. But its precise target remained unclear given that Mourinho’s players don’t resemble University Challenge contestants any more than Guardiola’s do. Since we’re on the subject of education, perhaps the most perceptive summing up of the controversy came from Emeritus Professor of Philosophy at the Universities of Burnage and Charlestown, Dr Liam Gallagher, who observed, “People banging on about not being able to celebrate after the derby, sit down and shut the fuck up you beige c**ts.” This is perhaps the level of analysis United’s complaints deserve.
There was a time when Mourinho wouldn’t have left himself open to such retorts. But it feels like his diversionary tactics of the last week weren’t just tactical. There is a personal element there which has grown into an obsession. Mourinho is Javert to Guardiola’s Valjean, determined to expose the crimes of his old adversary, seething that the world at large does not share his knowledge of his quarry’s perfidy. In the end Javert is destroyed by his own hatred. It’s remarkable how quickly the Guardiola-Mourinho rivalry has returned to the pattern set in Spain, something you’d have imagined the latter would have been keen to avoid.
There was an ignominious quality about Mourinho’s final season in Madrid which obscured the fact that he did pretty well there. One La Liga title and two runners-up slots behind a peak-form Barcelona doesn’t in itself constitute failure. It was Mourinho’s own truculence, frustration and tendency to get involved in foolish incidents which made it seem that way.
He’s doing well at the moment too. United are second in the table, and look the second-best team in the Premier League. For all the talk of their negativity, they are the second highest scorers in the league – 37 goals and 38 points from 17 matches are decent totals. It’s just that both pale into insignificance beside City’s 52 goals and 49 points. I’d imagine United fans are happy enough with Mourinho. For all the talk of ‘the exciting football the fans demand at this club’, their main problem with Louis van Gaal was his lack of success. Fans don’t care that much about the football if the results are forthcoming and second place would be United’s best league finish in five years.
What soured Real on Mourinho was behaviour as much as results. In his rivalry with Guardiola, Mourinho increasingly seemed to adopt the attitude of a junior Gaelic football manager confronted with clearly superior opposition, ‘Rise a row and see how smart they are then.’ He seemed to believe that Guardiola could be dragged into the gutter and that his performance would suffer from this. He still seems to believe this yet there’s absolutely no evidence that it’s true. After all the kerfuffle, City cruised to an imperious 4-0 win away to Swansea on Wednesday night while United were scraping past Bournemouth 1-0 at home.
Real’s fans seemed to feel that Mourinho’s attempts to drag Barcelona into a confrontation were beneath them. Could United’s supporters come to feel the same way? I’m not sure. There is, after all, not just a tolerance but a positive relish for this kind of nonsense among the supporters of English clubs. Mourinho will hope to convince the United fans that his feud with Guardiola is their feud too. Having gone down this road, he will have no option but to escalate things, especially if City continue to get the better of him. It is a depressing prospect.
Because the worst thing about the post-derby slanging matches is that they distract people from what really matters. Stuff like the sublime elegance and creativity of Leroy Sane in the Manchester derby, the thrilling old-school wing play of Mohamed Salah in its Merseyside equivalent, Burnley’s obdurate presence in the top six, the surprising adventurousness of Watford, Huddersfield’s defiance of the predictions which earmarked them for bottom spot, the power of Harry Kane, the revival of Wayne Rooney and of Leicester City, surprise packages like Pascal Gross at Brighton and Jamaal Lascelles at Newcastle.
If the Premier League has not quite regained its stature as the ‘best league in the world’ it’s certainly made significant steps in that direction and hasn’t looked this good for several seasons. Yet most of the talk in the last week has been of what happened off the pitch rather than on it. I suppose for Jose Mourinho, smarting from being outclassed once more by his old enemy, this might even count as an achievement of sorts. But it’s a pretty hollow one.
A real achievement is winning 15 league matches in a row while coaxing from your players the same kind of subtle and exhilarating football produced by your teams in Barcelona and Munich. Pep Guardiola rules OK. Everyone knows that.
Everyone except Jose Mourinho.
